Discover Culinary Gems in Nantucket

Disclosure: Simple Is More and our authors do not receive a commission through recommended links in this content. We do not have any conflicts of interest to disclose. Please visit our editorial policy, disclaimer policy, and terms of use for more information.

Welcome to Nantucket, an island with breathtaking coastal views and historic charm. Nestled about 30 miles off the coast of Cape Cod, the 14-mile long island Nantucket is a culinary treasure trove waiting to be discovered. You’ll enjoy walking along cobblestone streets, hikes, historic tours, the beach, and delicious food. You’ll find a diverse dining scene that offers everything from laid-back eateries to refined gourmet experiences to enjoy with friends and family.

Nantucket’s rich history as a former whaling capital is mirrored in its food culture. The array of restaurants that highlight fresh, locally sourced seafood is a nod to its maritime roots. Yet, Nantucket’s culinary scene is far from traditional. The local chefs and restaurateurs have a knack for blending classic New England flavors with innovative culinary techniques, making each dining experience both familiar and exciting. It’s a place where you can savor a traditional lobster roll one day and explore fusion sushi rolls the next.

Topper’s

Topper’s at The Wauwinet is a standout dining destination in Nantucket, renowned for its exquisite New England cuisine and unparalleled wine selection. With its stunning waterfront views and sophisticated ambiance, Topper’s offers an exceptional fine dining experience that embodies the island’s charm and elegance. Induldge in fresh seafood or savor a meticulously crafted dessert. Each dish at Topper’s is a testament to the culinary excellence that has made it a must-visit for food enthusiasts.

Millie’s

Millie’s is the quintessential spot for those seeking a blend of casual dining and scenic beauty. Located near Madaket Beach, it’s famous for its coastal-inspired dishes like fish tacos and lobster quesadillas, which are perfect accompaniments to the breathtaking sunset views. The laid-back atmosphere, combined with a menu that highlights fresh, local ingredients, makes Millie’s a beloved destination for both locals and tourists looking to enjoy a relaxed, flavorful meal.

The Club Car

The Club Car, situated in the heart of downtown Nantucket, offers a unique dining experience with its lively piano bar and seafood-focused menu. Known for its vibrant ambiance and live entertainment, The Club Car is where you can enjoy delectable dishes like steamed mussels and crab cakes while soaking in the island’s historic charm. It’s the perfect spot for an evening of great food, drinks, and music.

Galley Beach

Dining at Galley Beach is an experience like no other, with tables set right on the sand. Take in stunning views of Nantucket Sound. This restaurant combines the best of fine dining with a relaxed beachside atmosphere.

The menu features New American cuisine with a heavy focus on seafood, such as their famous yuzu butter-poached lobster. Paired with an extensive wine list and craft cocktails, Galley Beach offers a luxurious yet unpretentious dining experience that captures the essence of island life.

Proprietors Bar & Table

If you’re looking for a sophisticated, yet cozy dining experience, check out Proprietors Bar & Table. This restaurant is celebrated for its inventive small plates and exceptional cocktails.

The restaurant’s chic interior, combined with a menu that features globally inspired dishes using local ingredients, creates a unique culinary adventure. Whether you’re enjoying scallop crudo or smoked whitefish tea sandwiches, each bite at Proprietors is a delightful blend of flavors and texture.

Lola 41

Lola 41 stands out for its fusion of sushi and bistro dishes, offering a diverse menu that appeals to a wide range of tastes. Located near the beach, this restaurant is perfect for those who want to enjoy creative maki rolls, grilled salmon lo mein, or even a hearty burger with an English muffin bun. The eclectic menu, combined with a relaxed yet stylish atmosphere, makes Lola 41 a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Island Kitchen

Island Kitchen is a beloved year-round destination for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, known for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu. From classic eggs Benedict to refreshing açaí bowls and fish tacos, the dishes here cater to all tastes. The outdoor seating is particularly popular during the summer. This is an ideal spot to enjoy a meal in a relaxed, friendly setting.

Ventuno

Ventuno offers a taste of Italy in the heart of Nantucket, featuring a menu of delightful pasta, pizza, and Italian specialties. The restaurant’s cozy, inviting atmosphere and outstanding service make it a top choice for those craving authentic Italian cuisine. Each dish is prepared with care and creativity, ensuring a memorable dining experience that transports you straight to Italy.

The Chanticleer

The Chanticleer is an elegant dining spot that blends French and American cuisine in a charming, romantic setting. Known for its exquisite dishes and impeccable service, it’s the perfect place for a special occasion or a refined evening out. The restaurant’s beautiful garden setting and sophisticated menu, featuring items like escargot and duck confit, make it a standout choice for those seeking a high-end dining experience on the island.

The Nautilus

The Nautilus is a vibrant dining experience with its globally inspired menu and nautical-themed decor. Known for its artistic presentations and bold flavors, the restaurant serves standout dishes like Blue Crab Fried Rice and other seafood delights. Get ready to embark on a culinary voyage with the interior boat-like design.

Cisco Brewery

Cisco Brewery is the ultimate spot for après beach sips and snacks after a long exhausting day sitting on the beach or riding the waves. They are a local favorite, and their craft-brewed beers are found across the island.

Head to the ever-crowded Cisco in your beach day cover-up and flip-flops for live music, a variety of cocktail and beer options, and several delicious food trucks. Oh, and don’t forget the kids and dogs. It’s a fun and festive family atmosphere where large groups gather to enjoy the mild Nantucket weather, sip on cocktails, and compete at corn hole. 

Cru Nantucket Oyster Bar

For a sleek spot with a stunning view of the gorgeous yachts in the harbor, head to CRU. The seafood forward menu and raw bar are fan favorites, not to mention the craft-made cocktails at the bar, like the Crucomber.

With one of the best views on the whole island, this is a tough reservation to get, so plan accordingly. If you are lucky enough to get in, try the fresh oysters and the chilled lobster roll on toasted brioche. You won’t be sorry.  

Featured Image Credit: Depositphotos and jovannig